
Genre: Pop
Released: October 9, 2007
Alas, poor Vanessa Carlton lost her record deal, as she sings on her first single from Heroes and Thieves, "Nolita Fairytale". Well, no matter, because she's back with another album and ready to show A & M what they're missing! But, does she show them up? Well, the answer is yes and no.
On the one hand, this album is amazing: it's full of creativity and depth. On the other hand, these things weren't particularly lacking in her previous efforts, and the problem she had with her old label (lack of promotion) seems to plight this album as well - not because her label isn't trying.
At any rate, the album has wonderful flow to it. Carlton doesn't sing about light subject matter, yet keeps the pace and never gets lost in emotion. She adeptly jumps from an upbeat song like "Nolita Fairytale" to "Hands on Me" and "Spring Street", two of the albums most intimate songs. And then, without warning, she switches back to the upbeat "My Best" and "Come Undone" - and she does it like a pro. And, unlike most other artists of her age, she always writes her songs eloquently and cleverly, never sounding cliche or awkward.
And the instrumentals on the tracks are stunning - a string section, piano, drums, an organ... it's all there - but perhaps a bit too stunning. I first listened to "Heroes and Thieves", the title track, when it was just Vanessa and the piano, and I fell in love. When I heard it on the album, it was good, but it had lost some of it's intimacy. I would be very interested to listen to a sparser, more acoustic version of this album. Still, Carlton is able to weave a wonderful mixture of catchy refrains and instrument sections while still making a statement, which is more than I can say for Britney Spears, Lindsay Lohan, or her other female pop contemporaries.
Recommended Tracks: "Nolita Fairytale", "Hands on Me", "Fools Like Me", "Home"
RATING
Melody: 4/5 Lyrics: 4/5 "Catchiness" factor: 8/10
TOTAL: 8/10